Milburn review sets out ambitious plans to address NEET crisis
The final report from Alan Milburn’s Young People and Work review of high NEET levels sets out major reform to provide long-term solutions that address the underlying issues. In this article I have highlighted some of the key features of the report and the areas that relate most specifically to career development. For further understanding, I would encourage people to read at least the executive summary of the report to get a deeper understanding of the report’s findings and recommendations.
Unlike many reviews of this nature, Milburn’s report does not set out a series of individual recommendations that can be implemented in isolation or together. Instead, he is clear that his recommendations call for a complete overhaul of key systems related to young people and work. He says “Its aim is to change the life course of nearly one million young people who are not currently in education, employment or training. And to do the same for the generations that follow. It sets out a 10 year programme to deliver a new system to make it happen.”
He is clear that significantly reducing the number of young people not working is essential for the health of the nation as we need more young people in work to grow the economy and sustain the costs of supporting a growing older generation.
Key recommendations
The scale of ambition is huge. Milburn sees “a whole system failure” and calls for reform of the labour market, of the education system, the health system, welfare, and the removal of fragmentation of services across all these. He sets out a goal for an effective ‘NEET Zero’ rate of 5% to become one of the best performing comparable nations. Within 10 years “all of those young people who can participate, whether in education, training or employment, should be doing so”. For those who are unable to participate, they should receive support that gives them long-term protection.
The report calls for a more active partnership between government and employers to create more entry-level roles and opportunities to experience work. This includes government leading by example in offering roles and leveraging its purchasing power with contractors to offer opportunities. Government must make it easier and more attractive for employers to hire young people, including payments of at least £3,000 for those taking on young people at risk of NEET.
While he recognises the need for qualifications, Milburn calls for the education system to be judged more on whether young people successfully transition into further learning or work. Schools must deliver both knowledge and aptitude for success and technical and vocational education should be equal to academic routes.
The NHS should become less reactive and more proactive (or preventative) in supporting young people, so they don’t become ill and fall out of the system before receiving treatment, but rather are identified and supported to avoid detachment from learning and work.
The report calls for welfare changes – which received a lot of attention prior to the report’s publication – shifting from a system that can keep some young people out of work to one where participation is encouraged but security is available for those who can’t. Under-25s would be supported by a dedicated welfare system designed around their needs, which Milburn identifies as different from the older population. Young people will be expected to participate and will be supported to do so, shifting spend on young people from welfare to employment support.
The fragmentation of support will be addressed with the creation of a Youth Opportunity Service (YOS), bringing together a range of support services for young people. The key elements of the YOS are employment support (including careers advice), health and functional support, practical support (such as transportation costs) and wider support (such as housing or caring responsibilities). This service would be designed to be locally rather than nationally run.
What about career development?
As the report says, “Good careers guidance is critical. It needs to be more universal than it is at present. It also needs to be better aligned to progression into the labour market. Bringing careers advice under the umbrella of the YOS will help address those deficits. Government should ensure that every school and young person can access high-quality digital careers information, including AI-enabled tools, which bring together national and local labour-market information, pathways and earnings data in an accessible form. Technology should free more face-to-face capacity for young people who need it most, allowing young people at risk of becoming NEET to receive enhanced face-to-face guidance at the main decision points, with parents involved where appropriate.”
There is little focus on careers advice in education settings, with the majority of the focus on experiences of work and an understanding of the opportunities. There are a few key points made that are of direct interest to career development professionals.
In calling for better curriculum balance between knowledge and aptitude, and equalising the status of technical and vocational education with academic, the report says “work experience should become a statutory duty on schools and careers education should be integrated with employment support in the new Youth Opportunity Service. Experience of working life should become a normal part of education… A new ready-for-work standard should show whether young people leave school with the foundations, experience and confidence needed for the next stage. Work readiness data at school level should be published and the new standard inspected by Ofsted... a new outcome measure should be published…Schools should continue to be judged on attainment, but also on preparation and sustained outcomes… to broaden our definition of educational success.”
It says the evidence supports “repeated, cumulative contact and a flexible menu: careers encounters starting from primary school age, workplace visits, insight days, projects, job shadowing, shorter placements and more substantial work experience”. It recognises the unequal delivery of careers education and work experience in schools, “Work experience is often an afterthought for schools rather than a mainstream entitlement. It is also particularly dependent on parental networks…Careers education has improved, but too many young people – particularly the most disadvantaged – remain uncertain about the practical steps required to enter employment, especially if they are thinking about a vocational path.” Parents should be more deeply engaged in careers conversations from age 14.
It calls for early careers intervention that then runs throughout formal education, “Exposure to the world of work should be built across the school journey. In primary school, the purpose should be to broaden horizons and challenge occupational stereotypes rather than ask children to choose careers. During key stage 3, young people should accumulate meaningful exposure through employer projects, workplace visits, talks, enterprise activity and FE and apprenticeship tasters. By key stage 4 every young person who is able to, should experience a real workplace, normally including a substantial placement.”
Regarding the current issue of the new safeguarding regulations potentially limiting work experience opportunities with employers, the report calls for a single guide stating when a DBS check is required, and the testing of a “direct barred-list checking route, which schools can already access, and make checks required solely for government supported work experience free”.
The report also acknowledges the work of Careers Hubs and sees them as a key part of the local Youth Opportunity Services. Careers support “will be a core YOS function, not a parallel architecture. The place based youth careers and employer-brokerage functions currently delivered through the Careers & Enterprise Company's Careers Hubs will transfer into the YOS, bringing their employer relationships, local labour-market knowledge and delivery capability into one participation service. The relevant staff, funding and local employer-brokerage capability will move with those functions. Schools and colleges will retain their responsibilities for careers education and guidance, with the YOS providing the infrastructure around them. Digital support for all ages will continue through the new Jobs and Careers Service 'Work Hub' tool, which brings together AI-enabled job search, labour-market information and careers advice. Rather than duplicate this for young people, Work Hub and the YOS will join up so that young people can move easily between them. There will be no wrong front door for jobs, careers and skills support.”
Delivery timelines
This is a ten-year plan for a systemic redesign to address NEETs in a sustainable way. But it does set out an approach that begins work in the near term.
In the first 100 days, the programme should have a clear governance and implementation plan, and a confirmed legislative and funding timetable.
First changes should be delivered in 2027/2028, with an initial £500m investment to kickstart reform, including development of local Participation Plans and mobilisation of the central YOS function before integration of the existing services including Careers Hubs. The digital offer needs to be developed, and young people should be increasingly supported by the YOS. Work opportunities should be stimulated and education should focus on preventing disengagement and improving transition points through “improved data, key stage 3 checks and more flexible curriculum time”. Strategic authorities should map and publish local routes from education into work and study both for the benefit of young people, and to understand where there are gaps.
By the end of 2029, “every area should have a YOS or equivalent offer in place. Health should be fully integrated into regional governance. The Opportunity offer, Support offer and Health & Disability Fund offers should be guaranteed for any young person that needs them…Once an area has sufficiently established their YOS and connected support, all new claims for benefits for 18 to 24 year-olds will be to Youth Allowance, Additional Costs Allowance and the Severe and Complex Needs Insurance in that area.”
Beyond that, the public sector should be hiring young people and major contracts should include youth employment commitments. Youth Opportunity Services should be operating nationwide. In education, the curriculum should support stronger work exposure and better careers advice, with consistent and high-quality work experience for all. Entry-level jobs, apprenticeships, technical routes and supported opportunities should continue to grow.
There is much greater description of the proposed changes, evidence and impact modelling in the report, and many of the changes will require further development to understand the detail for implementation – such as how schools will deliver more consistency in careers education and advice, how careers advisers and careers hubs will operate as part of the Youth Opportunity Service and the relative emphasis placed on it.
This is an important review that sets out a transformative approach to supporting young people. We are yet to see how fully government backs it, and whether it can sustain the support of politicians over the ten-year period needed to deliver it.
You can read more in the summary and full Young People and Work reports.
Unlike many reviews of this nature, Milburn’s report does not set out a series of individual recommendations that can be implemented in isolation or together. Instead, he is clear that his recommendations call for a complete overhaul of key systems related to young people and work. He says “Its aim is to change the life course of nearly one million young people who are not currently in education, employment or training. And to do the same for the generations that follow. It sets out a 10 year programme to deliver a new system to make it happen.”
He is clear that significantly reducing the number of young people not working is essential for the health of the nation as we need more young people in work to grow the economy and sustain the costs of supporting a growing older generation.
Key recommendations
The scale of ambition is huge. Milburn sees “a whole system failure” and calls for reform of the labour market, of the education system, the health system, welfare, and the removal of fragmentation of services across all these. He sets out a goal for an effective ‘NEET Zero’ rate of 5% to become one of the best performing comparable nations. Within 10 years “all of those young people who can participate, whether in education, training or employment, should be doing so”. For those who are unable to participate, they should receive support that gives them long-term protection.
The report calls for a more active partnership between government and employers to create more entry-level roles and opportunities to experience work. This includes government leading by example in offering roles and leveraging its purchasing power with contractors to offer opportunities. Government must make it easier and more attractive for employers to hire young people, including payments of at least £3,000 for those taking on young people at risk of NEET.
While he recognises the need for qualifications, Milburn calls for the education system to be judged more on whether young people successfully transition into further learning or work. Schools must deliver both knowledge and aptitude for success and technical and vocational education should be equal to academic routes.
The NHS should become less reactive and more proactive (or preventative) in supporting young people, so they don’t become ill and fall out of the system before receiving treatment, but rather are identified and supported to avoid detachment from learning and work.
The report calls for welfare changes – which received a lot of attention prior to the report’s publication – shifting from a system that can keep some young people out of work to one where participation is encouraged but security is available for those who can’t. Under-25s would be supported by a dedicated welfare system designed around their needs, which Milburn identifies as different from the older population. Young people will be expected to participate and will be supported to do so, shifting spend on young people from welfare to employment support.
The fragmentation of support will be addressed with the creation of a Youth Opportunity Service (YOS), bringing together a range of support services for young people. The key elements of the YOS are employment support (including careers advice), health and functional support, practical support (such as transportation costs) and wider support (such as housing or caring responsibilities). This service would be designed to be locally rather than nationally run.
What about career development?
As the report says, “Good careers guidance is critical. It needs to be more universal than it is at present. It also needs to be better aligned to progression into the labour market. Bringing careers advice under the umbrella of the YOS will help address those deficits. Government should ensure that every school and young person can access high-quality digital careers information, including AI-enabled tools, which bring together national and local labour-market information, pathways and earnings data in an accessible form. Technology should free more face-to-face capacity for young people who need it most, allowing young people at risk of becoming NEET to receive enhanced face-to-face guidance at the main decision points, with parents involved where appropriate.”
There is little focus on careers advice in education settings, with the majority of the focus on experiences of work and an understanding of the opportunities. There are a few key points made that are of direct interest to career development professionals.
In calling for better curriculum balance between knowledge and aptitude, and equalising the status of technical and vocational education with academic, the report says “work experience should become a statutory duty on schools and careers education should be integrated with employment support in the new Youth Opportunity Service. Experience of working life should become a normal part of education… A new ready-for-work standard should show whether young people leave school with the foundations, experience and confidence needed for the next stage. Work readiness data at school level should be published and the new standard inspected by Ofsted... a new outcome measure should be published…Schools should continue to be judged on attainment, but also on preparation and sustained outcomes… to broaden our definition of educational success.”
It says the evidence supports “repeated, cumulative contact and a flexible menu: careers encounters starting from primary school age, workplace visits, insight days, projects, job shadowing, shorter placements and more substantial work experience”. It recognises the unequal delivery of careers education and work experience in schools, “Work experience is often an afterthought for schools rather than a mainstream entitlement. It is also particularly dependent on parental networks…Careers education has improved, but too many young people – particularly the most disadvantaged – remain uncertain about the practical steps required to enter employment, especially if they are thinking about a vocational path.” Parents should be more deeply engaged in careers conversations from age 14.
It calls for early careers intervention that then runs throughout formal education, “Exposure to the world of work should be built across the school journey. In primary school, the purpose should be to broaden horizons and challenge occupational stereotypes rather than ask children to choose careers. During key stage 3, young people should accumulate meaningful exposure through employer projects, workplace visits, talks, enterprise activity and FE and apprenticeship tasters. By key stage 4 every young person who is able to, should experience a real workplace, normally including a substantial placement.”
Regarding the current issue of the new safeguarding regulations potentially limiting work experience opportunities with employers, the report calls for a single guide stating when a DBS check is required, and the testing of a “direct barred-list checking route, which schools can already access, and make checks required solely for government supported work experience free”.
The report also acknowledges the work of Careers Hubs and sees them as a key part of the local Youth Opportunity Services. Careers support “will be a core YOS function, not a parallel architecture. The place based youth careers and employer-brokerage functions currently delivered through the Careers & Enterprise Company's Careers Hubs will transfer into the YOS, bringing their employer relationships, local labour-market knowledge and delivery capability into one participation service. The relevant staff, funding and local employer-brokerage capability will move with those functions. Schools and colleges will retain their responsibilities for careers education and guidance, with the YOS providing the infrastructure around them. Digital support for all ages will continue through the new Jobs and Careers Service 'Work Hub' tool, which brings together AI-enabled job search, labour-market information and careers advice. Rather than duplicate this for young people, Work Hub and the YOS will join up so that young people can move easily between them. There will be no wrong front door for jobs, careers and skills support.”
Delivery timelines
This is a ten-year plan for a systemic redesign to address NEETs in a sustainable way. But it does set out an approach that begins work in the near term.
In the first 100 days, the programme should have a clear governance and implementation plan, and a confirmed legislative and funding timetable.
First changes should be delivered in 2027/2028, with an initial £500m investment to kickstart reform, including development of local Participation Plans and mobilisation of the central YOS function before integration of the existing services including Careers Hubs. The digital offer needs to be developed, and young people should be increasingly supported by the YOS. Work opportunities should be stimulated and education should focus on preventing disengagement and improving transition points through “improved data, key stage 3 checks and more flexible curriculum time”. Strategic authorities should map and publish local routes from education into work and study both for the benefit of young people, and to understand where there are gaps.
By the end of 2029, “every area should have a YOS or equivalent offer in place. Health should be fully integrated into regional governance. The Opportunity offer, Support offer and Health & Disability Fund offers should be guaranteed for any young person that needs them…Once an area has sufficiently established their YOS and connected support, all new claims for benefits for 18 to 24 year-olds will be to Youth Allowance, Additional Costs Allowance and the Severe and Complex Needs Insurance in that area.”
Beyond that, the public sector should be hiring young people and major contracts should include youth employment commitments. Youth Opportunity Services should be operating nationwide. In education, the curriculum should support stronger work exposure and better careers advice, with consistent and high-quality work experience for all. Entry-level jobs, apprenticeships, technical routes and supported opportunities should continue to grow.
There is much greater description of the proposed changes, evidence and impact modelling in the report, and many of the changes will require further development to understand the detail for implementation – such as how schools will deliver more consistency in careers education and advice, how careers advisers and careers hubs will operate as part of the Youth Opportunity Service and the relative emphasis placed on it.
This is an important review that sets out a transformative approach to supporting young people. We are yet to see how fully government backs it, and whether it can sustain the support of politicians over the ten-year period needed to deliver it.
You can read more in the summary and full Young People and Work reports.
0 Comments
