CDI reaction to the Milburn review report
The CDI welcomes the ambition and system-wide solutions proposed by the Milburn review, but the commitment by this and future governments will be key and there is much to decide in the detail.
The NEETs issue is longstanding and will take time and sustained effort to address. It is to be applauded that Milburn and the team carrying out the review didn’t focus simply on some quick wins that would have had marginal impact. Instead, they have sought to understand the fundamental drivers of the issue and identify how the whole system needs to change to address them. While there will be elements of the proposals that different political and organisational groups will like or dislike, we can’t fault the scale and direction.
It is good to see that it hasn’t just focused narrowly on skills and education, but on the way the wider labour market works for young people, how health and social care restricts rather than enables young people’s participation and how the welfare system doesn’t recognise that young people’s needs differ from the older adult population.
From a career development perspective there are two broad areas of consideration; the context within which careers support is provided, and what that support looks like.
The wider context
The proposals make education less knowledge focused, more balanced with aptitude and increased time to learn about occupations and the world of work. It changes the measures of success from just qualifications to a broader focus on the transitions of young people into further learning and work. This is very welcome to ensure young people have a more rounded understanding and capability at the end of formal education. The report says;
“Knowledge matters, but so does the ability to apply it, communicate, work with others, solve problems and continue learning… The task is not to prepare young people for one job, or even one career. It is to prepare them for a working life in which jobs, technology and the skills they need will continue to evolve.”
It also outlines an environment where government works with employers to create more entry level opportunities – from work experiences to first jobs – a well-identified issue from Milburn’s interim report. This is positive from a career development perspective, as the increased requirements for work experience in schools is dependent on their availability, and more first-job vacancies give young people more options.
A welfare system designed to support young people and encourage them to participate is also welcome, though any reductions in support need to come after the support to participate have been bedded in, otherwise some of those most disadvantaged may be left most at risk. This, linked to the creation of the Youth Opportunity Service (YOS), could be a powerful combined support system.
The YOS brings together a range of support services, including careers, which may sound familiar to those working in careers in England before the early 2010s. While the intent is good, the lessons from the good and bad of the Connexions service need to be learned to ensure it is effective.
A YOS that provides consistent and more foundational support for schools and colleges would add huge value – driving employer engagement, creating and sharing local LMI, and offering supplementary careers support for disadvantaged young people as they transition could take some pressure off careers staff in schools.
Career development
Regarding career development more directly, the report is heavily focused on ensuring young people have experiences of work – from exposure to employers in the education environment through to work experience, placements and entry-level roles – and the need for this to start from primary school age. The curriculum changes also refer to careers education, but with little beyond understanding occupations and work.
While careers advice is referenced in the report, there is virtually no acknowledgement of the value of careers advice beyond understanding and choosing options for transition. It doesn’t recognise the need for, and value of, careers advice to help young people understand themselves, the barriers they face and why different options may be more or less suitable. There is surprisingly little on the need for the individual to understand themselves given how much of the report focuses on the need for the system to recognise the needs of individuals.
Where careers education, work experience and careers advice are referenced in schools and colleges, the importance of it being consistent or even targeted to those needing it most is highlighted, but there is nothing on how that will be achieved. While many of the proposals are very welcome, our main concerns would be that the current system does not allow government to ensure schools provide a set level of support with committed resources, we know that careers professionals in schools are already struggling to deliver the existing requirements as they are under resourced, and low salaries make it hard to attract and retain qualified careers staff.
The creation of the YOS offers opportunities and risks. There are already concerns that the careers offering could be overwhelmed in the much larger employability role of the new Service. If this is subsumed into an even larger YOS, the design, funding and accountability measures must ensure that the role of career guidance is maintained and strengthened. There is a risk that the other support services will be seen as addressing the wider barriers young people face and careers will be relegated to an after-thought at the end of this process to help them make a transition into work, rather than as an integrated part of this earlier work. By understanding themselves and the options available, careers advisers can help young people understand and overcome barriers, build confidence and see the potential if they participate.
The new YOS named advisers are welcomed, but their role must be clear and they must be properly trained to link young people to the services they require. They cannot do the job of a qualified careers adviser and must fully understand the careers service role and when and how to direct young people to them.
The other aspect of YOS that presents both benefits and risks is the drive for devolved implementation. Having local services that understand local needs and have the flexibility to meet those needs is creditable. But it also risks creating a different basis of fragmentation, of services being dependent on regional political views and variable competence in delivery. It needs a national framework and standards to minimise this, coupled with regional plans and local delivery within that.
Summary
Overall, it is extremely welcome that the report recognises that there is no single solution, and that this needs to be a long-term, sustained approach to addressing the NEET crisis. But while the report sets out an ambition and a direction, there is so much dependent on the detail and the actions of successive governments.
There have already been some positive steps towards creating this new approach – such as the creation of the Jobs and Careers Service, though we are yet to see how that will work. This government needs to set out a clear plan for implementation that shows its commitment to the report recommendations, and as key aspects are implemented, government needs to consult with the experts on the detail – including the career development profession to ensure its broader and deeper benefits aren’t lost in a focus on work experience and occupational understanding.
It needs cross-party commitment to achieve its long-term goals. The report highlights the opportunity to create schools that nurture, educate and prepare young people for their lives and careers, to create a labour market where young people can gain their first experiences of work, to receive genuine careers and employment support as they transition between education and work stages, with preventative health approaches and a welfare system that encourages and rewards participation while ensuring that those who cannot participate are not left struggling.
All this is to be applauded, but so much is dependent on the government response and the involvement of career development experts to inform the detailed decisions needed throughout design and implementation.
You can read the CDI’s overview of the report more in the summary and full Young People and Work reports.
The NEETs issue is longstanding and will take time and sustained effort to address. It is to be applauded that Milburn and the team carrying out the review didn’t focus simply on some quick wins that would have had marginal impact. Instead, they have sought to understand the fundamental drivers of the issue and identify how the whole system needs to change to address them. While there will be elements of the proposals that different political and organisational groups will like or dislike, we can’t fault the scale and direction.
It is good to see that it hasn’t just focused narrowly on skills and education, but on the way the wider labour market works for young people, how health and social care restricts rather than enables young people’s participation and how the welfare system doesn’t recognise that young people’s needs differ from the older adult population.
From a career development perspective there are two broad areas of consideration; the context within which careers support is provided, and what that support looks like.
The wider context
The proposals make education less knowledge focused, more balanced with aptitude and increased time to learn about occupations and the world of work. It changes the measures of success from just qualifications to a broader focus on the transitions of young people into further learning and work. This is very welcome to ensure young people have a more rounded understanding and capability at the end of formal education. The report says;
“Knowledge matters, but so does the ability to apply it, communicate, work with others, solve problems and continue learning… The task is not to prepare young people for one job, or even one career. It is to prepare them for a working life in which jobs, technology and the skills they need will continue to evolve.”
It also outlines an environment where government works with employers to create more entry level opportunities – from work experiences to first jobs – a well-identified issue from Milburn’s interim report. This is positive from a career development perspective, as the increased requirements for work experience in schools is dependent on their availability, and more first-job vacancies give young people more options.
A welfare system designed to support young people and encourage them to participate is also welcome, though any reductions in support need to come after the support to participate have been bedded in, otherwise some of those most disadvantaged may be left most at risk. This, linked to the creation of the Youth Opportunity Service (YOS), could be a powerful combined support system.
The YOS brings together a range of support services, including careers, which may sound familiar to those working in careers in England before the early 2010s. While the intent is good, the lessons from the good and bad of the Connexions service need to be learned to ensure it is effective.
A YOS that provides consistent and more foundational support for schools and colleges would add huge value – driving employer engagement, creating and sharing local LMI, and offering supplementary careers support for disadvantaged young people as they transition could take some pressure off careers staff in schools.
Career development
Regarding career development more directly, the report is heavily focused on ensuring young people have experiences of work – from exposure to employers in the education environment through to work experience, placements and entry-level roles – and the need for this to start from primary school age. The curriculum changes also refer to careers education, but with little beyond understanding occupations and work.
While careers advice is referenced in the report, there is virtually no acknowledgement of the value of careers advice beyond understanding and choosing options for transition. It doesn’t recognise the need for, and value of, careers advice to help young people understand themselves, the barriers they face and why different options may be more or less suitable. There is surprisingly little on the need for the individual to understand themselves given how much of the report focuses on the need for the system to recognise the needs of individuals.
Where careers education, work experience and careers advice are referenced in schools and colleges, the importance of it being consistent or even targeted to those needing it most is highlighted, but there is nothing on how that will be achieved. While many of the proposals are very welcome, our main concerns would be that the current system does not allow government to ensure schools provide a set level of support with committed resources, we know that careers professionals in schools are already struggling to deliver the existing requirements as they are under resourced, and low salaries make it hard to attract and retain qualified careers staff.
The creation of the YOS offers opportunities and risks. There are already concerns that the careers offering could be overwhelmed in the much larger employability role of the new Service. If this is subsumed into an even larger YOS, the design, funding and accountability measures must ensure that the role of career guidance is maintained and strengthened. There is a risk that the other support services will be seen as addressing the wider barriers young people face and careers will be relegated to an after-thought at the end of this process to help them make a transition into work, rather than as an integrated part of this earlier work. By understanding themselves and the options available, careers advisers can help young people understand and overcome barriers, build confidence and see the potential if they participate.
The new YOS named advisers are welcomed, but their role must be clear and they must be properly trained to link young people to the services they require. They cannot do the job of a qualified careers adviser and must fully understand the careers service role and when and how to direct young people to them.
The other aspect of YOS that presents both benefits and risks is the drive for devolved implementation. Having local services that understand local needs and have the flexibility to meet those needs is creditable. But it also risks creating a different basis of fragmentation, of services being dependent on regional political views and variable competence in delivery. It needs a national framework and standards to minimise this, coupled with regional plans and local delivery within that.
Summary
Overall, it is extremely welcome that the report recognises that there is no single solution, and that this needs to be a long-term, sustained approach to addressing the NEET crisis. But while the report sets out an ambition and a direction, there is so much dependent on the detail and the actions of successive governments.
There have already been some positive steps towards creating this new approach – such as the creation of the Jobs and Careers Service, though we are yet to see how that will work. This government needs to set out a clear plan for implementation that shows its commitment to the report recommendations, and as key aspects are implemented, government needs to consult with the experts on the detail – including the career development profession to ensure its broader and deeper benefits aren’t lost in a focus on work experience and occupational understanding.
It needs cross-party commitment to achieve its long-term goals. The report highlights the opportunity to create schools that nurture, educate and prepare young people for their lives and careers, to create a labour market where young people can gain their first experiences of work, to receive genuine careers and employment support as they transition between education and work stages, with preventative health approaches and a welfare system that encourages and rewards participation while ensuring that those who cannot participate are not left struggling.
All this is to be applauded, but so much is dependent on the government response and the involvement of career development experts to inform the detailed decisions needed throughout design and implementation.
You can read the CDI’s overview of the report more in the summary and full Young People and Work reports.
0 Comments
